Monitoring and evaluating the ecological integrity of forest ecosystems
Abstract
“Ecological integrity” provides a useful framework for ecologically based monitoring and can provide valuable information for assessing ecosystem condition and management effectiveness. Building on the related concepts of biological integrity and ecological health, ecological integrity is a measure of the composition, structure, and function of an ecosystem in relation to the system's natural or historical range of variation, as well as perturbations caused by natural or anthropogenic agents of change. We have developed a protocol to evaluate the ecological integrity of temperate zone, forested ecosystems, based on long‐term monitoring data. To do so, we identified metrics of status and trend in structure, composition, and function of forests impacted by multiple agents of change. We used data, models, and the scientific literature to interpret and report integrity using “stoplight” symbology, ie “Good” (green), “Caution” (yellow), or “Significant Concern” (red). Preliminary data indicate that forested ecosystems in Acadia National Park have retained ecological integrity across a variety of metrics, but that some aspects of soil chemistry and stand structure indicate potential problems. This protocol was developed for the National Park Service Vital Signs Monitoring Program and holds promise for application in the temperate zone, forested ecosystems of eastern North America.
Number of times cited: 53
- Hyeone Park and Eric Higgs, A criteria and indicators monitoring framework for food forestry embedded in the principles of ecological restoration, Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 190, 3, (2018).
- Jennifer K. Costanza, Don Faber-Langendoen, John W. Coulston and David N. Wear, Classifying forest inventory data into species-based forest community types at broad extents: exploring tradeoffs among supervised and unsupervised approaches, Forest Ecosystems, 10.1186/s40663-017-0123-x, 5, 1, (2018).
- J. Fourie, M. Sedibe and M. Muller, The Experiences of Foundation Phase Teachers Regarding Reading Literacy Interventions at an Underperforming School in Gauteng Province, Interchange, (2018).
- Cindy Chu, Lucy Ellis and Derrick T. Kerckhove, Effectiveness of terrestrial protected areas for conservation of lake fish communities, Conservation Biology, 32, 3, (607-618), (2018).
- Franz Mora, A spatial framework for detecting anthropogenic impacts on predator-prey interactions that sustain ecological integrity in Mexico, Ecological Processes, 10.1186/s13717-018-0146-4, 7, 1, (2018).
- Stephanie Mansourian, John A. Stanturf, Mercy Afua Adutwumwaa Derkyi and Vera Lex Engel, Forest Landscape Restoration: increasing the positive impacts of forest restoration or simply the area under tree cover?, Restoration Ecology, 25, 2, (178-183), (2017).
- Philip K Roche and C Sylvie Campagne, From ecosystem integrity to ecosystem condition: a continuity of concepts supporting different aspects of ecosystem sustainability, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 29, (63), (2017).
- Franz Mora, A structural equation modeling approach for formalizing and evaluating ecological integrity in terrestrial ecosystems, Ecological Informatics, 41, (74), (2017).
- Mark A. White, Meredith W. Cornett and Peter T. Wolter, Two scales are better than one: Monitoring multiple-use northern temperate forests, Forest Ecology and Management, 384, (44), (2017).
- Nashieli Garcia-Alaniz, Miguel Equihua, Octavio Pérez-Maqueo, Julián Equihua Benítez, Pedro Maeda, Fernando Pardo Urrutia, José J Flores Martínez, Sergio A Villela Gaytán and Michael Schmidt, The Mexican National Biodiversity and Ecosystem Degradation Monitoring System, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 26-27, (62), (2017).
- Heath M. Hagy, Christopher S. Hine, Michelle M. Horath, Aaron P. Yetter, Randolph V. Smith and Joshua D. Stafford, Waterbird response indicates floodplain wetland restoration, Hydrobiologia, 804, 1, (119), (2017).
- Franz Mora, Nation-wide indicators of ecological integrity in Mexico: The status of mammalian apex-predators and their habitat, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2017.06.030, 82, (94-105), (2017).
- Orphé Bichet, Angélique Dupuch, Christian Hébert, Hélène Le Borgne and Daniel Fortin, Maintaining animal assemblages through single‐species management: the case of threatened caribou in boreal forest, Ecological Applications, 26, 2, (612-623), (2016).
- Christine M. Lucas, Pervaze Sheikh, Paul R. Gagnon and David G. McGrath, How livestock and flooding mediate the ecological integrity of working forests in Amazon River floodplains, Ecological Applications, 26, 1, (190-202), (2016).
- Zachary S. Ladin, Conor D. Higgins, John Paul Schmit, Geoffrey Sanders, Mark J. Johnson, Aaron S. Weed, Matthew R. Marshall, J. Patrick Campbell, James A. Comiskey and W. Gregory Shriver, Using regional bird community dynamics to evaluate ecological integrity within national parks, Ecosphere, 7, 9, (2016).
- Virginia Capmourteres and Madhur Anand, “Conservation value”: a review of the concept and its quantification, Ecosphere, 7, 10, (2016).
- E. William Schweiger, James B. Grace, David Cooper, Ben Bobowski and Mike Britten, Using structural equation modeling to link human activities to wetland ecological integrity, Ecosphere, 7, 11, (2016).
- Virginia Capmourteres and Madhur Anand, Assessing ecological integrity: A multi-scale structural and functional approach using Structural Equation Modeling, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2016.07.006, 71, (258-269), (2016).
- Abd Rahman Kassim, Muhammad Afizzul Misman, Mohd Azahari Faidi and Hamdan Omar, A tool for assessing ecological status of forest ecosystem, IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 37, (012026), (2016).
- Eleanor D. Brown and Byron K. Williams, Ecological integrity assessment as a metric of biodiversity: are we measuring what we say we are?, Biodiversity and Conservation, 25, 6, (1011), (2016).
- David J. Burke, Chad Knisely, Michael L. Watson, Sarah R. Carrino-Kyker and Ronald L. Mauk, The effects of agricultural history on forest ecological integrity as determined by a rapid forest assessment method, Forest Ecology and Management, 378, (1), (2016).
- Zachary Wurtzebach and Courtney Schultz, Measuring Ecological Integrity: History, Practical Applications, and Research Opportunities, BioScience, 10.1093/biosci/biw037, 66, 6, (446-457), (2016).
- André Arsenault and Guy Larocque, Indicators of Forest Ecosystem Integrity, Ecological Forest Management Handbook, 10.1201/b19150-17, (361-380), (2016).
- Winfried Schröder, Stefan Nickel, Martin Jenssen and Jan Riediger, Methodology to assess and map the potential development of forest ecosystems exposed to climate change and atmospheric nitrogen deposition: A pilot study in Germany, Science of The Total Environment, 521-522, (108), (2015).
- Jun Yang, Guanghui Dai and Shurong Wang, China’s National Monitoring Program on Ecological Functions of Forests: An Analysis of the Protocol and Initial Results, Forests, 6, 12, (809), (2015).
- John A. Stanturf, Future landscapes: opportunities and challenges, New Forests, 10.1007/s11056-015-9500-x, 46, 5-6, (615-644), (2015).
- P.F.E. Addison, L.B. Flander and C.N. Cook, Are we missing the boat? Current uses of long-term biological monitoring data in the evaluation and management of marine protected areas, Journal of Environmental Management, 149, (148), (2015).
- Carolyn G. Mahan, John A. Young, Bruce J. Miller and Michael C. Saunders, Using Ecological Indicators and a Decision Support System for Integrated Ecological Assessment at Two National Park Units in the Mid-Atlantic Region, USA, Environmental Management, 10.1007/s00267-014-0391-y, 55, 2, (508-522), (2014).
- Cassia F. Read, David H. Duncan, Peter A. Vesk, Jane Elith and Shiqiang Wan, Biocrust morphogroups provide an effective and rapid assessment tool for drylands, Journal of Applied Ecology, 51, 6, (1740-1749), (2014).
- Don Faber-Langendoen, Todd Keeler-Wolf, Del Meidinger, Dave Tart, Bruce Hoagland, Carmen Josse, Gonzalo Navarro, Serguei Ponomarenko, Jean-Pierre Saucier, Alan Weakley and Patrick Comer, EcoVeg: a new approach to vegetation description and classification, Ecological Monographs, 84, 4, (533-561), (2014).
- Sarah E. Goodwin and W. Gregory Shriver, Using a bird community index to evaluate national parks in the urbanized national capital region, Urban Ecosystems, 17, 4, (979), (2014).
- John A. Stanturf, Brian J. Palik and R. Kasten Dumroese, Contemporary forest restoration: A review emphasizing function, Forest Ecology and Management, 331, (292), (2014).
- S. Kalisz, R. B. Spigler and C. C. Horvitz, In a long-term experimental demography study, excluding ungulates reversed invader's explosive population growth rate and restored natives, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111, 12, (4501), (2014).
- Todd R. Lookingbill, John Paul Schmit, Samantha M. Tessel, Marcela Suarez-Rubio and Robert H. Hilderbrand, Assessing national park resource condition along an urban–rural gradient in and around Washington, DC, USA, Ecological Indicators, 42, (147), (2014).
- Ksenia S. Egorova and Valentine P. Ananikov, Toxicity of Ionic Liquids: Eco(cyto)activity as Complicated, but Unavoidable Parameter for Task‐Specific Optimization, ChemSusChem, 7, 2, (336-360), (2014).
- Philip J. Burton, Considerations for Monitoring and Evaluating Forest Restoration, Journal of Sustainable Forestry, 33, sup1, (S149), (2014).
- David Tucker, Stuart H. Gage, Ian Williamson and Susan Fuller, Linking ecological condition and the soundscape in fragmented Australian forests, Landscape Ecology, 29, 4, (745), (2014).
- Kathryn M. Miller and Brian R. Mitchell, A new tool for power analysis of fixed plot data: Using simulations and mixed effects models to evaluate forest metrics, Ecosphere, 5, 9, (1-23), (2014).
- Suzanne Sanders and Jessica Grochowski, Alternative Metrics for Evaluating Forest Integrity and Assessing Change at Four Northern-tier U.S. National Parks, The American Midland Naturalist, 171, 2, (185), (2014).
- Rupert Seidl, Chris S. Eastaugh, Koen Kramer, Michael Maroschek, Christopher Reyer, Jarosław Socha, Giorgio Vacchiano, Tzvetan Zlatanov and Hubert Hasenauer, Scaling issues in forest ecosystem management and how to address them with models, European Journal of Forest Research, 132, 5-6, (653), (2013).
- David A. Keith, Jon Paul Rodríguez, Kathryn M. Rodríguez-Clark, Emily Nicholson, Kaisu Aapala, Alfonso Alonso, Marianne Asmussen, Steven Bachman, Alberto Basset, Edmund G. Barrow, John S. Benson, Melanie J. Bishop, Ronald Bonifacio, Thomas M. Brooks, Mark A. Burgman, Patrick Comer, Francisco A. Comín, Franz Essl, Don Faber-Langendoen, Peter G. Fairweather, Robert J. Holdaway, Michael Jennings, Richard T. Kingsford, Rebecca E. Lester, Ralph Mac Nally, Michael A. McCarthy, Justin Moat, María A. Oliveira-Miranda, Phil Pisanu, Brigitte Poulin, Tracey J. Regan, Uwe Riecken, Mark D. Spalding, Sergio Zambrano-Martínez and Matteo Convertino, Scientific Foundations for an IUCN Red List of Ecosystems, PLoS ONE, 8, 5, (e62111), (2013).
- Donald R. Schoolmaster, James B. Grace, E. William Schweiger, Glenn R. Guntenspergen, Brian R. Mitchell, Kathryn M. Miller and Amanda M. Little, An algorithmic and information-theoretic approach to multimetric index construction, Ecological Indicators, 26, (14), (2013).
- William J. McShea, Ecology and management of white‐tailed deer in a changing world, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1249, 1, (45-56), (2012).
- James B. Grace, Donald R. Schoolmaster, Glenn R. Guntenspergen, Amanda M. Little, Brian R. Mitchell, Kathryn M. Miller and E. William Schweiger, Guidelines for a graph‐theoretic implementation of structural equation modeling, Ecosphere, 3, 8, (1-44), (2012).
- Jesse Caputo, Commoditization and the Origins of American Silviculture, Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society, 32, 1, (86), (2012).
- S. Winter, Forest naturalness assessment as a component of biodiversity monitoring and conservation management, Forestry, 85, 2, (293), (2012).
- Tanner B. Harris, Nishanta Rajakaruna, Sarah J. Nelson and Peter D. Vaux, Stressors and threats to the flora of Acadia National Park, Maine: Current knowledge, information gaps, and future directions1, The Journal of the Torrey Botanical Society, 139, 3, (323), (2012).
- Jeffrey G. Holmquist, Jennifer R. Jones, Jutta Schmidt-Gengenbach, Lyra F. Pierotti and Jason P. Love, Terrestrial and Aquatic Macroinvertebrate Assemblages as a Function of Wetland Type across a Mountain Landscape, Arctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, 43, 4, (568), (2011).
- Susanne Winter, Hagen S. Fischer and Anton Fischer, Relative Quantitative Reference Approach for Naturalness Assessments of forests, Forest Ecology and Management, 259, 8, (1624), (2010).
- James Angelo, Brean Duncan and John Weishampel, Using Lidar-Derived Vegetation Profiles to Predict Time since Fire in an Oak Scrub Landscape in East-Central Florida, Remote Sensing, 2, 12, (514), (2010).
- Alan A. Ager, Nicole M. Vaillant and Mark A. Finney, A comparison of landscape fuel treatment strategies to mitigate wildland fire risk in the urban interface and preserve old forest structure, Forest Ecology and Management, 259, 8, (1556), (2010).
- Eddy Van Der Maarel, Long‐Term Environmental Monitoring , Encyclopedia of Environmetrics, (2013).
- Stephani G. Zador, Kirstin K. Holsman, Kerim Y. Aydin and Sarah K. Gaichas, Ecosystem considerations in Alaska: the value of qualitative assessments, ICES Journal of Marine Science: Journal du Conseil, 10.1093/icesjms/fsw144, (fsw144), (2016).




