Journal list menu
Article
Biotic mechanisms of community stability shift along a precipitation gradient
Corresponding Editor: G. A. Fox.
Abstract
Understanding how biotic mechanisms confer stability in variable environments is a fundamental quest in ecology, and one that is becoming increasingly urgent with global change. Several mechanisms, notably a portfolio effect associated with species richness, compensatory dynamics generated by negative species covariance and selection for stable dominant species populations can increase the stability of the overall community. While the importance of these mechanisms is debated, few studies have contrasted their importance in an environmental context. We analyzed nine long‐term data sets of grassland species composition to investigate how two key environmental factors, precipitation amount and variability, may directly influence community stability and how they may indirectly influence stability via biotic mechanisms. We found that the importance of stability mechanisms varied along the environmental gradient: strong negative species covariance occurred in sites characterized by high precipitation variability, whereas portfolio effects increased in sites with high mean annual precipitation. Instead of questioning whether compensatory dynamics are important in nature, our findings suggest that debate should widen to include several stability mechanisms and how these mechanisms vary in importance across environmental gradients.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 58
- Siwei Liang, Xinchang Kou, Yingbin Li, Xiaotao Lü, Jingkuan Wang, Qi Li, Soil nematode community composition and stability under different nitrogen additions in a semiarid grassland, Global Ecology and Conservation, 10.1016/j.gecco.2020.e00965, (e00965), (2020).
- Michael Kalyuzhny, Null models for community dynamics: Beware of the cyclic shift algorithm, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 10.1111/geb.13083, 29, 6, (1085-1093), (2020).
- Line Holm Andersen, Anna Sofie Krag Skærbæk, Thomas Bo Sørensen, Jeppe Storgaard Knudsen, Cino Pertoldi, Simon Bahrndorff, Dan Bruhn, Turnover and change in plant species composition in a shielded salt marsh following variation in precipitation and temperature, Journal of Vegetation Science, 10.1111/jvs.12863, 31, 3, (465-475), (2020).
- Mei Zhou, Qian Yang, Hongjin Zhang, Xiaodong Yao, Wenjing Zeng, Wei Wang, Plant community temporal stability in response to nitrogen addition among different degraded grasslands, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.138886, 729, (138886), (2020).
- Yonghui Wang, Xiaxia Niu, Liqing Zhao, Cunzhu Liang, Bailing Miao, Qing Zhang, Jinghui Zhang, Bernhard Schmid, Wenhong Ma, Biotic stability mechanisms in Inner Mongolian grassland, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 10.1098/rspb.2020.0675, 287, 1928, (20200675), (2020).
- Théophile Olivier, Elisa Thébault, Marianne Elias, Benoit Fontaine, Colin Fontaine, Urbanization and agricultural intensification destabilize animal communities differently than diversity loss, Nature Communications, 10.1038/s41467-020-16240-6, 11, 1, (2020).
- Lei Zhao, Shaopeng Wang, Lauren M. Hallett, Andrew L. Rypel, Lawrence W. Sheppard, Max C. N. Castorani, Lauren G. Shoemaker, Kathryn L. Cottingham, Katharine Suding, Daniel C. Reuman, A new variance ratio metric to detect the timescale of compensatory dynamics, Ecosphere, 10.1002/ecs2.3114, 11, 5, (2020).
- Benjamin Gilbert, Andrew S. MacDougall, Taku Kadoya, Munemitsu Akasaka, Joseph R. Bennett, Eric M. Lind, Habacuc Flores‐Moreno, Jennifer Firn, Yann Hautier, Elizabeth T. Borer, Eric W. Seabloom, Peter B. Adler, Elsa E. Cleland, James B. Grace, William Stanley Harpole, Ellen H. Esch, Joslin L. Moore, Johannes Knops, Rebecca McCulley, Brent Mortensen, Jonathan Bakker, Philip A. Fay, Climate and local environment structure asynchrony and the stability of primary production in grasslands, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 10.1111/geb.13094, 29, 7, (1177-1188), (2020).
- Jonathan A. Walter, Rachel Fleck, Michael L. Pace, Grace M. Wilkinson, Scaling relationships between lake surface area and catchment area, Aquatic Sciences, 10.1007/s00027-020-00726-y, 82, 3, (2020).
- Enrique Valencia, Francesco de Bello, Thomas Galland, Peter B. Adler, Jan Lepš, Anna E-Vojtkó, Roel van Klink, Carlos P. Carmona, Jiří Danihelka, Jürgen Dengler, David J. Eldridge, Marc Estiarte, Ricardo García-González, Eric Garnier, Daniel Gómez‐García, Susan P. Harrison, Tomáš Herben, Ricardo Ibáñez, Anke Jentsch, Norbert Juergens, Miklós Kertész, Katja Klumpp, Frédérique Louault, Rob H. Marrs, Romà Ogaya, Gábor Ónodi, Robin J. Pakeman, Iker Pardo, Meelis Pärtel, Begoña Peco, Josep Peñuelas, Richard F. Pywell, Marta Rueda, Wolfgang Schmidt, Ute Schmiedel, Martin Schuetz, Hana Skálová, Petr Šmilauer, Marie Šmilauerová, Christian Smit, MingHua Song, Martin Stock, James Val, Vigdis Vandvik, David Ward, Karsten Wesche, Susan K. Wiser, Ben A. Woodcock, Truman P. Young, Fei-Hai Yu, Martin Zobel, Lars Götzenberger, Synchrony matters more than species richness in plant community stability at a global scale, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 10.1073/pnas.1920405117, 117, 39, (24345-24351), (2020).
- Congyan Wang, Mei Wei, Shu Wang, Bingde Wu, Huiyuan Cheng, Erigeron annuus (L.) Pers. and Solidago canadensis L. antagonistically affect community stability and community invasibility under the co-invasion condition, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.137128, 716, (137128), (2020).
- Jiri Dolezal, Pavel Fibich, Jan Altman, Jan Leps, Shigeru Uemura, Koichi Takahashi, Toshihiko Hara, Determinants of ecosystem stability in a diverse temperate forest, Oikos, 10.1111/oik.07379, 0, 0, (2020).
- Joan Dudney, Katharine N. Suding, The elusive search for tipping points, Nature Ecology & Evolution, 10.1038/s41559-020-1273-8, (2020).
- Hui Fu, Guixiang Yuan, Korhan Özkan, Liselotter Sander Johansson, Martin Søndergaard, Torben L. Lauridsen, Erik Jeppesen, Patterns of Seasonal Stability of Lake Phytoplankton Mediated by Resource and Grazer Control During Two Decades of Re-oligotrophication, Ecosystems, 10.1007/s10021-020-00557-w, (2020).
- In-Hwan Cho, Ha-Kyung Kim, Min-Hyuk Lee, Yong-Jae Kim, Hyuk Lee, Baik-Ho Kim, The Effect of Monsoon Rainfall Patterns on Epilithic Diatom Communities in the Hantangang River, Korea, Water, 10.3390/w12051471, 12, 5, (1471), (2020).
- Loralee Larios, John L. Maron, Voles mediate functional trait diversity along a resource gradient, Functional Ecology, 10.1111/1365-2435.13686, 0, 0, (2020).
- Sara Tomiolo, Mark C. Bilton, Katja Tielbörger, Plant community stability results from shifts in species assemblages following whole community transplants across climates, Oikos, 10.1111/oik.06536, 129, 1, (70-80), (2019).
- Xuehua Ye, Zhilan Liu, Shudong Zhang, Shuqin Gao, Guofang Liu, Qinguo Cui, Juan Du, Zhenying Huang, Johannes H.C. Cornelissen, Experimental sand burial and precipitation enhancement alter plant and soil carbon allocation in a semi-arid steppe in north China, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.10.208, 651, (3099-3106), (2019).
- Hui Fu, Guixiang Yuan, Erik Jeppesen, Dabing Ge, Dongsheng Zou, Qian Lou, Taotao Dai, Wei Li, Jiayou Zhong, Zhenrong Huang, Qiaolin Liu, Aiping Wu, Multiple stabilizing pathways in wetland plant communities subjected to an elevation gradient, Ecological Indicators, 10.1016/j.ecolind.2019.05.049, 104, (704-710), (2019).
- Congyan Wang, Mei Wei, Bingde Wu, Shu Wang, Kun Jiang, Alpine grassland degradation reduced plant species diversity and stability of plant communities in the Northern Tibet Plateau, Acta Oecologica, 10.1016/j.actao.2019.05.005, 98, (25-29), (2019).
- Bingrong Zhou, Shuai Li, Fu Li, Shikui Dong, Fulin Ma, Shengcui Zhu, Huakun Zhou, Paul Stufkens, Plant functional groups asynchrony keep the community biomass stability along with the climate change- a 20-year experimental observation of alpine meadow in eastern Qinghai-Tibet Plateau, Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 10.1016/j.agee.2019.06.002, 282, (49-57), (2019).
- Noelline Tsafack, Letizia Di Biase, Yingzhong Xie, Xinpu Wang, Simone Fattorini, Carabid community stability is enhanced by carabid diversity but reduced by aridity in Chinese steppes, Acta Oecologica, 10.1016/j.actao.2019.103450, 99, (103450), (2019).
- Shu Wang, Mei Wei, Bingde Wu, Kun Jiang, Daolin Du, Congyan Wang, Degree of invasion of Canada goldenrod (Solidago canadensis L.) plays an important role in the variation of plant taxonomic diversity and community stability in eastern China, Ecological Research, 10.1111/1440-1703.12049, 34, 6, (782-789), (2019).
- Yonggang Chi, Zhuwen Xu, Lei Zhou, Qingpeng Yang, Shuxia Zheng, Shao‐peng Li, Differential roles of species richness versus species asynchrony in regulating community stability along a precipitation gradient, Ecology and Evolution, 10.1002/ece3.5857, 9, 24, (14244-14252), (2019).
- Alfonso Pineda, Óscar Peláez, Juliana Déo Dias, Bianca Trevizan Segovia, Cláudia Costa Bonecker, Luiz Felipe Machado Velho, Luzia Cleide Rodrigues, The El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is the main source of variation for the gamma diversity of plankton communities in subtropical shallow lakes, Aquatic Sciences, 10.1007/s00027-019-0646-z, 81, 3, (2019).
- Matthias S. Thomsen, Jasmin A. Godbold, Clement Garcia, Stefan G. Bolam, Ruth Parker, Martin Solan, Compensatory responses can alter the form of the biodiversity–function relation curve, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 10.1098/rspb.2019.0287, 286, 1901, (20190287), (2019).
- Fabien Verniest, Sabine Greulich, Methods for assessing the effects of environmental parameters on biological communities in long-term ecological studies - A literature review, Ecological Modelling, 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2019.108732, 414, (108732), (2019).
- Y. Anny Chung, Scott L. Collins, Jennifer A. Rudgers, Connecting plant–soil feedbacks to long‐term stability in a desert grassland, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.2756, 100, 8, (2019).
- Thomas Lamy, Shaopeng Wang, Delphine Renard, Kevin D. Lafferty, Daniel C. Reed, Robert J. Miller, Species insurance trumps spatial insurance in stabilizing biomass of a marine macroalgal metacommunity, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.2719, 100, 7, (2019).
- Anne E. Magurran, Maria Dornelas, Faye Moyes, Peter A. Henderson, Temporal β diversity—A macroecological perspective, Global Ecology and Biogeography, 10.1111/geb.13026, 28, 12, (1949-1960), (2019).
- Yangyang Jia, Zhaoyong Shi, Zhichao Chen, Florian Walder, Changyan Tian, Gu Feng, Soil moisture threshold in controlling above- and belowground community stability in a temperate desert of Central Asia, Science of The Total Environment, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.134650, (134650), (2019).
- Xiaoyun Hou, Shiliang Liu, Shuang Zhao, Shikui Dong, Yongxiu Sun, Robert Beazley, The alpine meadow around the mining areas on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau will degenerate as a result of the change of dominant species under the disturbance of open-pit mining, Environmental Pollution, 10.1016/j.envpol.2019.113111, (113111), (2019).
- Congyan Wang, Bingde Wu, Kun Jiang, Jiawei Zhou, Jun Liu, Yanna Lv, Canada goldenrod invasion cause significant shifts in the taxonomic diversity and community stability of plant communities in heterogeneous landscapes in urban ecosystems in East China, Ecological Engineering, 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2018.10.002, (2018).
- Cameron Wagg, Jan‐Hendrik Dudenhöffer, Franco Widmer, Marcel G. A. Heijden, Linking diversity, synchrony and stability in soil microbial communities, Functional Ecology, 10.1111/1365-2435.13056, 32, 5, (1280-1292), (2018).
- Pablo García-Palacios, Nicolas Gross, Juan Gaitán, Fernando T. Maestre, Climate mediates the biodiversity–ecosystem stability relationship globally, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 10.1073/pnas.1800425115, 115, 33, (8400-8405), (2018).
- Jan Douda, Jana Doudová, Josef Hulík, Alena Havrdová, Karel Boublík, Reduced competition enhances community temporal stability under conditions of increasing environmental stress, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.2466, 99, 10, (2207-2216), (2018).
- Scott L. Collins, Meghan L. Avolio, Corinna Gries, Lauren M. Hallett, Sally E. Koerner, Kimberly J. La Pierre, Andrew L. Rypel, Eric R. Sokol, Samuel B. Fey, Dan F. B. Flynn, Sydney K. Jones, Laura M. Ladwig, Julie Ripplinger, Matt B. Jones, Temporal heterogeneity increases with spatial heterogeneity in ecological communities, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.2154, 99, 4, (858-865), (2018).
- Martin Korňan, Marek Svitok, Pairwise null model analyses of temporal patterns of bird assemblages contradict the assumptions of competition theory, Basic and Applied Ecology, 10.1016/j.baae.2018.07.001, 31, (72-81), (2018).
- Dylan Craven, Nico Eisenhauer, William D. Pearse, Yann Hautier, Forest Isbell, Christiane Roscher, Michael Bahn, Carl Beierkuhnlein, Gerhard Bönisch, Nina Buchmann, Chaeho Byun, Jane A. Catford, Bruno E. L. Cerabolini, J. Hans C. Cornelissen, Joseph M. Craine, Enrica De Luca, Anne Ebeling, John N. Griffin, Andy Hector, Jes Hines, Anke Jentsch, Jens Kattge, Jürgen Kreyling, Vojtech Lanta, Nathan Lemoine, Sebastian T. Meyer, Vanessa Minden, Vladimir Onipchenko, H. Wayne Polley, Peter B. Reich, Jasper van Ruijven, Brandon Schamp, Melinda D. Smith, Nadejda A. Soudzilovskaia, David Tilman, Alexandra Weigelt, Brian Wilsey, Peter Manning, Multiple facets of biodiversity drive the diversity–stability relationship, Nature Ecology & Evolution, 10.1038/s41559-018-0647-7, 2, 10, (1579-1587), (2018).
- Jan Lepš, Maria Májeková, Alena Vítová, Jiří Doležal, Francesco Bello, Stabilizing effects in temporal fluctuations: management, traits, and species richness in high‐diversity communities, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.2065, 99, 2, (360-371), (2017).
- Ziting Wang, Lu Liu, Qing Chen, Xiaoxia Wen, Yang Liu, Juan Han, Yuncheng Liao, Conservation tillage enhances the stability of the rhizosphere bacterial community responding to plant growth, Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 10.1007/s13593-017-0454-6, 37, 5, (2017).
- Ronald E. Abbott, Daniel F. Doak, Megan L. Peterson, Portfolio effects, climate change, and the persistence of small populations: analyses on the rare plant Saussurea weberi, Ecology, 10.1002/ecy.1738, 98, 4, (1071-1081), (2017).
- Lauren M. Hallett, Claudia Stein, Katharine N. Suding, Functional diversity increases ecological stability in a grazed grassland, Oecologia, 10.1007/s00442-016-3802-3, 183, 3, (831-840), (2017).
- Nicholas J. Gotelli, Hideyasu Shimadzu, Maria Dornelas, Brian McGill, Faye Moyes, Anne E. Magurran, Community-level regulation of temporal trends in biodiversity, Science Advances, 10.1126/sciadv.1700315, 3, 7, (e1700315), (2017).
- Zhiyuan Ma, Huiying Liu, Zhaorong Mi, Zhenhua Zhang, Yonghui Wang, Wei Xu, Lin Jiang, Jin-Sheng He, Climate warming reduces the temporal stability of plant community biomass production, Nature Communications, 10.1038/ncomms15378, 8, (15378), (2017).
- Claire Laguionie-Marchais, Gordon L.J. Paterson, Brian J. Bett, Kenneth L. Smith, Henry A. Ruhl, Inter-annual species-level variations in an abyssal polychaete assemblage (Sta. M, NE Pacific, 4000 m), Progress in Oceanography, 10.1016/j.pocean.2015.10.006, 140, (43-53), (2016).
- Habacuc Flores-Moreno, Peter B. Reich, Eric M. Lind, Lauren L. Sullivan, Eric W. Seabloom, Laura Yahdjian, Andrew S. MacDougall, Lara G. Reichmann, Juan Alberti, Selene Báez, Jonathan D. Bakker, Marc W. Cadotte, Maria C. Caldeira, Enrique J. Chaneton, Carla M. D'Antonio, Philip A. Fay, Jennifer Firn, Nicole Hagenah, W. Stanley Harpole, Oscar Iribarne, Kevin P. Kirkman, Johannes M. H. Knops, Kimberly J. La Pierre, Ramesh Laungani, Andrew D. B. Leakey, Rebecca L. McCulley, Joslin L. Moore, Jesus Pascual, Elizabeth T. Borer, Climate modifies response of non-native and native species richness to nutrient enrichment, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 10.1098/rstb.2015.0273, 371, 1694, (20150273), (2016).
- Sydney K. Jones, Scott L. Collins, John M. Blair, Melinda D. Smith, Alan K. Knapp, Altered rainfall patterns increase forb abundance and richness in native tallgrass prairie, Scientific Reports, 10.1038/srep20120, 6, 1, (2016).
- Devan Allen McGranahan, Torre J. Hovick, R. Dwayne Elmore, David M. Engle, Samuel D. Fuhlendorf, Stephen L. Winter, James R. Miller, Diane M. Debinski, Temporal variability in aboveground plant biomass decreases as spatial variability increases, Ecology, 10.1890/15-0906.1, 97, 3, (555-560), (2016).
- Lauren M. Hallett, Sydney K. Jones, A. Andrew M. MacDonald, Matthew B. Jones, Dan F. B. Flynn, Julie Ripplinger, Peter Slaughter, Corinna Gries, Scott L. Collins, codyn: An r package of community dynamics metrics, Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 10.1111/2041-210X.12569, 7, 10, (1146-1151), (2016).
- D. C. Reed, J. C. Nelson, S. L. Harrer, R. J. Miller, Estimating biomass of benthic kelp forest invertebrates from body size and percent cover data, Marine Biology, 10.1007/s00227-016-2879-x, 163, 5, (2016).
- Edy Fantinato, Silvia Del Vecchio, Antonio Slaviero, Luisa Conti, Alicia Teresa Rosario Acosta, Gabriella Buffa, Does flowering synchrony contribute to the sustainment of dry grassland biodiversity?, Flora - Morphology, Distribution, Functional Ecology of Plants, 10.1016/j.flora.2016.04.003, 222, (96-103), (2016).
- Casey B. Nolan, Daniel L. Tufford, David R. Chalcraft, Needs Assessment of Coastal Land Managers for Drought Onset Indicators in the Southeastern United States, Journal of Coastal Research, 10.2112/JCOASTRES-D-15-00182.1, 321, (1016-1024), (2016).
- Kristin L. Vanderbilt, Chau-Chin Lin, Sheng-Shan Lu, Abd Rahman Kassim, Honglin He, Xuebing Guo, Inigo San Gil, David Blankman, John H. Porter, Fostering ecological data sharing: collaborations in the International Long Term Ecological Research Network, Ecosphere, 10.1890/ES14-00281.1, 6, 10, (1-18), (2015).
- Melinda D. Smith, Kimberly J. La Pierre, Scott L. Collins, Alan K. Knapp, Katherine L. Gross, John E. Barrett, Serita D. Frey, Laura Gough, Robert J. Miller, James T. Morris, Lindsey E. Rustad, John Yarie, Global environmental change and the nature of aboveground net primary productivity responses: insights from long-term experiments, Oecologia, 10.1007/s00442-015-3230-9, 177, 4, (935-947), (2015).
- Alan K. Knapp, Charles J. W. Carroll, Elsie M. Denton, Kimberly J. La Pierre, Scott L. Collins, Melinda D. Smith, Differential sensitivity to regional-scale drought in six central US grasslands, Oecologia, 10.1007/s00442-015-3233-6, 177, 4, (949-957), (2015).
- Erica N. Spotswood, James W. Bartolome, Barbara Allen-Diaz, Hotspots of Community Change: Temporal Dynamics Are Spatially Variable in Understory Plant Composition of a California Oak Woodland, PLOS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0133501, 10, 7, (e0133501), (2015).
- Zhuwen Xu, Haiyan Ren, Jiangping Cai, Ruzhen Wang, Mai-He Li, Shiqiang Wan, Xingguo Han, Bernard J. Lewis, Yong Jiang, Effects of experimentally-enhanced precipitation and nitrogen on resistance, recovery and resilience of a semi-arid grassland after drought, Oecologia, 10.1007/s00442-014-3081-9, 176, 4, (1187-1197), (2014).
